Elon Musk ordered Nvidia to ship thousands of AI chips reserved for Tesla to X and xAI | MuaneToraya

1 week ago 13

Elon Musk, Chief Executive Officer of SpaceX and Tesla and proprietor of X speaks astatine the Milken Conference 2024 Global Conference Sessions astatine The Beverly Hilton successful Beverly Hills, California, U.S., May 6, 2024. 

David Swanson | Reuters

Elon Musk claims helium tin turn Tesla into "a person successful AI & robotics," an ambition that he's said volition necessitate a batch of pricey processors from Nvidia to physique up its infrastructure.

On Tesla's first-quarter earnings telephone successful April, Musk said the electrical conveyance institution volition summation the fig of progressive H100s — Nvidia's flagship artificial quality spot — from 35,000 to 85,000 by the extremity of this year. He besides wrote successful a station connected X a fewer days aboriginal that Tesla would walk $10 cardinal this twelvemonth "in combined grooming and inference AI."

But emails written by Nvidia elder unit and wide shared wrong the institution suggest that Musk presented an exaggerated representation of Tesla's procurement to shareholders. Correspondence from Nvidia staffers besides indicates that Musk diverted a sizable shipment of AI processors that had been reserved for Tesla to his societal media institution X, formerly known arsenic Twitter.

Shares slipped arsenic overmuch arsenic 1% connected the quality successful premarket trading.

By ordering Nvidia to fto privately held X leap the enactment up of Tesla, Musk pushed backmost the automaker's receipt of much than $500 cardinal successful graphics processing units, oregon GPUs, by months, apt adding to delays successful mounting up the supercomputers Tesla says it needs to make autonomous vehicles and humanoid robots.

"Elon prioritizing X H100 GPU clump deployment astatine X versus Tesla by redirecting 12k of shipped H100 GPUs primitively slated for Tesla to X instead," an Nvidia memo from December said. "In exchange, archetypal X orders of 12k H100 slated for Jan and June to beryllium redirected to Tesla."

A much caller Nvidia email, from precocious April, said Musk's remark connected the first-quarter Tesla telephone "conflicts with bookings" and that his April station connected X astir $10 cardinal successful AI spending besides "conflicts with bookings and FY 2025 forecasts." The email referenced quality astir Tesla's ongoing, drastic layoffs and warned that headcount reductions could origin further delays with an "H100 project" astatine Tesla's Texas Gigafactory.

The caller accusation from the emails, work by , highlights an escalating struggle betwixt Musk and immoderate agitated Tesla shareholders who question whether the billionaire CEO is fulfilling his obligations to Tesla portion besides moving a postulation of different companies that necessitate his attention, resources and hefty amounts of capital.

A spokesperson for Nvidia declined to remark for this story. Musk and representatives for X and Tesla did not respond to requests for comment.

Critics person said Musk is only a part-time CEO of Tesla, the institution liable for the immense bulk of his wealth. Musk is besides the CEO of aerospace institution SpaceX, the laminitis of brain-computer interface startup Neuralink and tunneling task The Boring Co. He besides owns X, which helium acquired for $44 cardinal successful precocious 2022, erstwhile it was inactive called Twitter. He launched his AI startup, xAI, successful 2023.

X and xAI are tightly intertwined. In a post connected X successful November, Musk wrote, "X Corp investors volition ain 25% of xAI." Additionally, xAI uses immoderate capableness successful X information centers to tally immoderate of its grooming and inference for the ample connection models down its chatbot, called Grok, has learned.

Musk has pitched Grok, primitively named Truth GPT, arsenic a politically incorrect chatbot with "a rebellious streak" and a would-be rival to OpenAI's ChatGPT and different generative AI services.

While Musk juggles his galore ventures, Tesla shareholders person crushed for concern. The institution is successful the midst of a troubling income diminution owed successful portion to its aging lineup of electrical vehicles and accrued competition. Its estimation has besides suffered successful the U.S., according to the Axios Harris Poll 100 survey, which attributed immoderate of the slippage to Musk's "antics" and "political rants."

Tesla's banal terms is down 29% this year.

Why Tesla is losing stock  successful  Europe

Rather than sermon EV income oregon the massive restructuring underway astatine Tesla, Musk has been encouraging investors to absorption connected aboriginal products that he's been promising for years but has yet to deliver. That includes AI bundle to crook existing cars into self-driving vehicles, dedicated robotaxis that tin marque wealth for their owners, and a driverless proscription network.

"If idiosyncratic doesn't believe Tesla's going to lick autonomy, I deliberation they should not beryllium an capitalist successful the company," Musk said connected the April net call. "We will, and we are."

To get there, he's said, Tesla requires plentifulness of Nvidia's GPUs which are specialized for AI grooming and workloads. Those chips are successful constricted proviso owed to soaring request from Google, Amazon, Meta, Microsoft, OpenAI and others.

'Consuming each GPU that's retired there'

Nvidia, present the third-most-valuable institution successful the satellite with a $2.8 trillion marketplace cap, has said it's hard to support up with demand. Between the unreality work providers and the companies processing AI models, customers "are consuming each GPU that's retired there," Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang said connected an net telephone successful May, aft the chipmaker reported its 3rd consecutive 4th of much than 200% gross growth.

Huang besides said, connected an net telephone successful February, that Nvidia does its champion to "allocate reasonably and to debar allocating unnecessarily," adding "why allocate thing erstwhile the information center's not ready?"

In naming customers that are already utilizing Nvidia's next-generation Blackwell platform, Huang mentioned xAI connected the May telephone alongside six of the biggest tech companies connected the satellite arsenic good arsenic Tesla.

Jensen Huang, co-founder and main enforcement serviceman of Nvidia Corp., during the Nvidia GPU Technology Conference (GTC) successful San Jose, California, US, connected Tuesday, March 19, 2024. 

David Paul Morris | Bloomberg | Getty Images

Musk likes to tout his infrastructure spending astatine some companies.

At Tesla, Musk has promised to physique a $500 million "Dojo" supercomputer successful Buffalo, New York, and a "super dense, water-cooled supercomputer cluster" astatine the company's mill successful Austin, Texas. The exertion would perchance assistance Tesla make the machine imaginativeness and LLMs needed for robots and autonomous vehicles.

At xAI, which is racing to vie with OpenAI, Anthropic, Google and others successful processing generative AI products, Musk is besides seeking to physique "the world's largest GPU cluster" successful North Dakota, with immoderate capableness online successful June, according to an interior Nvidia email from February.

The memo described a "Musk mandate" to marque each 100,000 chips disposable to xAI by the extremity of 2024. It noted that the LLM down xAI's Grok was relying connected Amazon and Oracle unreality infrastructure, with X providing further information halfway capacity.

The Information antecedently reported immoderate details of xAI's information halfway ambitions.

On May 26, xAI said it closed a $6 cardinal financing round led by galore of the aforesaid investors who funded Musk's Twitter takeover. The institution was incorporated successful March 2023, but Tesla didn't disclose its enactment astatine the time, and it was 4 months aboriginal earlier Musk publically introduced the startup.

Conflicts of interest

While Musk has said for years that Tesla is simply a person successful AI, helium wrote successful a post connected X successful January that he'd privation much power implicit the institution earlier pushing further successful that direction.

"I americium uncomfortable increasing Tesla to beryllium a person successful AI & robotics without having ~25% voting control. Enough to beryllium influential, but not truthful overmuch that I can't beryllium overturned," helium said successful the post.

Tesla's latest proxy filing indicates Musk has 20.5% of the company's outstanding shares, a fig that includes options awarded to Musk arsenic portion of his unprecedented 2018 CEO wage package. A Delaware tribunal has ordered that compensation to beryllium rescinded. Post-trial proceedings are ongoing and taxable to appeal.

If helium is incapable to scope his desired ownership mark, Musk said successful the January post, helium "would similar to physique products extracurricular of Tesla." He's already doing that astatine xAI.

Musk's comments astatine the clip rankled immoderate longstanding bulls, including the company's largest retail shareholder, Leo Koguan, and Gerber Kawasaki's Ross Gerber, who characterized his request arsenic "blackmail."

Joel Fleming, a securities litigator astatine Equity Litigation Group, said that by letting his backstage companies skip up of Tesla successful procuring captious hardware, Musk is making his conflicts of involvement readily apparent.

"When you person idiosyncratic similar Mr. Musk who is simply a fiduciary to aggregate companies, the instrumentality recognizes this creates conflict," Fleming said. "If you beryllium fiduciary duties to 2 oregon much companies that are competing implicit the aforesaid things, you whitethorn extremity up channeling firm accidental distant from 1 institution to another."

Fleming, who often represents nationalist institution investors successful shareholder disputes, said that successful specified situations, different executives would beryllium successful the champion presumption to marque decisions, portion those who are conflicted should abstain.

"That has not historically been the way that Mr. Musk has chosen for himself," Fleming said.

Musk hasn't been shy astir intermingling firm resources among his companies.

For example, pursuing his buyout of Twitter, Musk enlisted dozens of Autopilot bundle engineers and different method and administrative employees from Tesla to assistance him marque sweeping changes astatine the company. Some employees adjacent enactment for 2 Musk companies astatine once.

At xAI, Musk has besides attracted employees distant from Tesla, including machine-learning idiosyncratic Ethan Knight, and astatine slightest 4 different erstwhile Tesla employees who had been progressive successful Autopilot and large information projects determination earlier joining the startup.

A erstwhile Tesla proviso concatenation analyst, who asked not to beryllium named successful bid to sermon delicate matters, told that Musk has ever considered his companies arsenic an hold of his persona and believed helium tin bash immoderate helium wants with them. That includes Tesla's 2016 acquisition of SolarCity, wherever helium was president and a apical shareholder.

However, the idiosyncratic said, redirecting a ample shipment of chips from Tesla to X is extreme, fixed the scarcity of Nvidia's technology. The determination means the automaker willingly gave up precious clip that could person been utilized to physique retired its supercomputer clump successful Texas oregon New York and beforehand the models down its self-driving bundle and robotics.

WATCH: Nvidia is simply a 1 of 1 company

Nvidia is simply a 'one-of-one company,' says FirstMark's Rick Heitzmann